Back
Dr Jane Gaukroger

Be more resilient – by challenging conventional wisdom

Introduction

It’s Friday the 13th and my IT isn’t working. A major global outage has caused problems for millions of users and Radio 4 is carrying an article questioning the resilience of our technology infrastructure. Against a backdrop of climate change and global instability we are encouraged to stockpile food and water.  Emergency response scenarios are explored.

— 
This is tough…

It’s Friday the 13th and my IT isn’t working. A major global outage has caused problems for millions of users and Radio 4 is carrying an article questioning the resilience of our technology infrastructure. Against a backdrop of climate change and global instability we are encouraged to stockpile food and water. Emergency response scenarios are explored.

‍

At least for the moment no one has suggested a mindfulness programme might be the answer to these resilience challenges.

‍

The language of resilience has been very present for many years on the organisational wellbeing agenda, including in the legal profession. It appears in training catalogues and talent frameworks, firms run workshops and use apps to strengthen it and it gets discussed in feedback when staff are having a difficult time. Much of this is well intentioned. Legal careers are demanding and the world feels increasingly volatile, complex and uncertain. People benefit from understanding how they respond to the pressure which inevitably arises.

— 
Resilience scepticism

But in our coaching work with lawyers at every level, we hear growing scepticism about the way resilience is framed primarily as something the individual needs to develop when the system starts to strain. We share this concern.

‍

The pressures on lawyers are well documented: billable hours targets, clients who expect immediate responses, matters running late into the night and across weekends and a promotion system that rewards those who can sustain all of this for years. Many of these conditions link to how work is priced, organised, staffed and distributed.

‍

When someone begins to struggle within this system, the usual response is to look at the person. The lawyer who is exhausted after months of tight deadlines is quietly invited to see this as a personal shortfall. How well are they managing their time and priorities? Might a mindfulness course help to reduce feelings of stress? A lunchtime resilience session on managing feelings of overwhelm is far easier to arrange than a conversation about real overload from uneven work distribution or weak processes.

‍

Watching seniors with relentless work habits also disheartens those looking for a more balanced way of working. I have coached a number of very capable senior associates being encouraged on the partnership pathway, but deterred by a vision of careers built on heroic endurance. And it’s not unusual to hear a returner from parental leave or someone managing a health condition worry their resilience will be questioned if they decline a late meeting or another piece of work on top of an already full load.

‍

Over time, all of this shapes the culture. People question whether it’s a life they want. And many firms still wonder why diverse talent thins out.

— 
Wise resilience

None of this means resilience doesn’t matter. But we think it requires a more balanced and integrated approach and different mindsets can be useful. If we think of resilience with an engineering mindset the focus is helping strengthen the tolerance of the existing system to withstand unusual forces placed on it. But it might sometimes be wise to take a more ecological view noticing when the system isn’t sustainable and allowing something new to evolve.

‍

Coaching can support development of wise resilience in different ways.

‍

Wise resilience – individual

‍

Of course there is value in understanding individually what drains and restores us, how we behave under pressure and developing ways to manage emotional responses through stress. I recently heard a highly respected senior leader warn of the very real health risks of mistaking adrenalin for resilience. For individuals wise resilience means much more than staying calm and battening down the hatches when things get tough. It means understanding better the beliefs, both personal and cultural, that keep you saying yes when it would be wiser to say no. Many high-performing lawyers have never been invited to examine this, because careers have rewarded ‘pushing through’. Pausing, taking time to think and recentre are conditions for good judgement, yet senior professionals routinely treat them as optional luxuries. Coaching can help build everyday practices that protect such vital space, even in the most pressured periods.

‍

Equally important is having the confidence to negotiate workload, set expectations with clients and colleagues, and raise concerns about unwise workloads and practices. Coaching can support individuals to find the language and courage for conversations to explore options and possibilities for constructive change. This is a long way from teaching people simply to absorb more.

‍

Wise resilience – collective

‍

It matters how leaders set the tone. Partners who role-model a balanced approach and who are as ready to discuss workload pressures as work content and billing give colleagues permission to do the same. True resilience for the firm means creating a culture of psychological safety where people feel able to raise concerns. Coaching can help senior leaders understand and be more deliberate about the shadow they cast.

‍

More broadly, when coaching is happening across a firm it is often possible to see themes emerging: recurring pressure points, patterns in particular teams, common experiences at certain career stages. Shared anonymously and constructively, these insights give leadership a much clearer picture of where the system and people are straining. It’s a more ecological perspective. Firms who act on the picture – uncomfortable though it might sometimes be – tend to see the benefits of addressing wider and longer-term sustainability issues rather than just scheduling another wellbeing workshop which transfers responsibility to the individual and evades root causes. Coaching interventions are targeted to prevent rather than respond to burn-out.

— 
A question to consider

If your firm talks a great deal about resilience, it may be worth asking about the load the word is being asked to carry. How much is it describing a firm-wide capability or are individuals being expected to absorb most of the pressure?

‍

The honest answer probably says a good deal about how resilient you are to weather storms ahead.

— 
About the author

Dr Jane Gaukroger has over 30 years’ experience as an executive coach and organisational and leadership development consultant. She has worked with global consulting firms on a wide range of people development assignments and has served on practice leadership teams. Jane supports leaders at key transitions, helping them build confidence, clarity of purpose and everyday practices to sustain integrity, hope and calm in complex, uncertain conditions. She holds a doctorate in organisational wisdom from Leeds University Business School and has led research for the European Mentoring and Coaching Council on leading wisely. She is co-founder of the Practical Wisdom Network of professionals at the Collaborating Centre for Values-Based Practice, St Catherine’s College, Oxford.

— 

The Tall Wall works with law firms to design and deliver coaching programmes that support lawyers through demanding careers and key transitions, and shares anonymised themes to help firms address the conditions behind them. If you’d like to talk through what this could look like in your firm, get in touch.

— 
— 
— 
— 
— 
— 
—